Testimony of a Married Man with Same-Sex Attraction

I was reading over on my friend Joshua’s blog and came across this amazing article he wrote.  As one who is married and does still have same-sex attractions, I think he can authoritatively speak on the the issue where most others must remain silent from lack of knowledge and experience.

“[…]So many people with same-sex attraction believe they should pursue same-sex relationships in order to be true to themselves. They avoid marriage because they believe it would be dishonest for their spouse. Those already married leave their marriages because they believe that is what they should do. Those who want to obey the commandments of God are being ridiculed and told they are being dishonest, and those trying to help them are being told they are hurting them. Marriages are being broken apart, lives are being destroyed, souls are lost, and the wounded suffer in silence and are denied the healing power of the atonement, all in the name of acceptance and open-mindedness.I have chosen to focus on the divine nature and destiny of gay men and women partially because of the political atmosphere, but also because I think it is a strong example of how destructive a false view of one’s identity could be. We all face challenges to our identity. Whatever the temptation may be, there are those lined up to tell us we would be happier embracing that desire rather than going through the pains of repentance. We must be strong. If we remember who we are, we will be able to ignore Satan, and continue with faith and fulfill our destiny. And that will bring true joy, which is the whole reason why we exist.[…]”

Read the whole article:

One of the first lines from The Family: A Proclamation to the World reads: “All human beings—male and female—are created in the image of God. Each is a beloved spirit son or daughter of heavenly parents, and, as such, each has a divine nature and destiny.”1Our nature is that we are children of God.2 Our destiny is to have joy.3 This joy comes from following the commandments of God.4 We must accept Christ and take upon us his name.5

One of the greatest joys is found in the family, which is one reason we are commanded to multiply and replenish the Earth.6 Our destiny is to be exalted, together as a family. Being God’s children, we are to inherit all that he has.7Of course, all that isn’t going to happen here. There are children who die before being able to accept Christ, and many others who live their whole lives without even hearing of the gospel. Other people, for whatever reason, will never have the chance to get married in this life. But God is just, and it will all work out in the end. However, we must understand the goal that we are working towards. Understanding that goal is key in helping us fulfill our divine nature and identity. Once we understand our own purpose, we can help others to understand and fulfill their destiny.

Since our identities are so essential to the Lord’s plan, our identities are often under attack. It is this attack of which I wish to speak of today. Our identities are under attack by what we think of ourselves, how we see other people, and how we act according to those identities. One of the ways our identities are attacked is through labels. We use labels everyday. It is how we identify what we are talking about.

However, labels can be used to hurt or limit the capacity of our fellow man. These labels are powerful, and whether they are true or not, they take a hold of our hearts, and lead us to action. This is one of the reasons it is so important that we take upon ourselves the name of Christ. If this is our identity, it will lead to act according to the commands of God. However, if we choose some other label as our main identity, we become weak, for we are only as strong as that label. When Satan came to Moses and told him to worship him, Moses replied: “Who art thou? For behold, I am a son of God, in the similitude of his Only Begotten; and where is thy glory, that I should worship thee?”8 If Moses had responded “Who art thou? For behold, I am Moses, a prince of Egypt,” he would not have had the same result.

Elder Holland tells the story of one man who let one of these labels diminish his self worth and distract him from his divine identity. He states:

A pleasant young man in his early 20s sat across from me. He had an engaging smile, although he didn’t smile often during our talk. What drew me in was the pain in his eyes.

“I don’t know if I should remain a member of the Church,” he said. “I don’t think I’m worthy.”

“Why wouldn’t you be worthy?” I asked.

“I’m gay.”
I suppose he thought I would be startled. I wasn’t. “And … ?” I inquired.

A flicker of relief crossed his face as he sensed my continued interest. “I’m not attracted to women. I’m attracted to men.

I’ve tried to ignore these feelings or change them, but …”

He sighed. “Why am I this way? The feelings are very real.”

I paused, then said, “I need a little more information before advising you. You see, same-gender attraction is not a sin, but acting on those feelings is—just as it would be with heterosexual feelings. Do you violate the law of chastity?”

He shook his head. “No, I don’t.”

This time I was relieved. “Thank you for wanting to deal with this,” I said. “It takes courage to talk about it, and I honor you for keeping yourself clean.

“As for why you feel as you do, I can’t answer that question. A number of factors may be involved, and they can be as different as people are different. Some things, including the cause of your feelings, we may never know in this life. But knowing why you feel as you do isn’t as important as knowing you have not transgressed. If your life is in harmony with the commandments, then you are worthy to serve in the Church, enjoy full fellowship with the members, attend the temple, and receive all the blessings of the Savior’s Atonement.”

He sat up a little straighter. I continued, “You serve yourself poorly when you identify yourself primarily by your sexual feelings. That isn’t your only characteristic, so don’t give it disproportionate attention. You are first and foremost a son of God, and He loves you.

“What’s more, I love you. My Brethren among the General Authorities love you.”9

One of the things that struck me about this story was the pain the young man’s eyes. When Satan came to him, and told him he wasn’t worthy, he didn’t say “Who art thou? I am a son of God.” He said “You’re right, I’m gay.” He ended up believing Satan’s lies that he wasn’t worthy, and hence Satan was able to prevent this man from having joy, and replaced his deserved joy with pain.

Does this happen to you?

Does Satan cloud your mind from your true identity, and tell you that you are not worthy of God’s love? Does he replace your core identity with some other identity, that isn’t nearly as important your true identity as a beloved child of God?

Satan uses many tricks to do this. We may look around and think of ourselves as less talented, less skilled, not as faithful, or not as beautiful as those around us. When Satan comes and tells us we aren’t worthy, we too might bow our heads and agree with him, “You’re right, I’m not as good as so and so at such and such.”

God gives us our gifts. God gives us our weaknesses. Everything we have we have received from the Lord. He knows what we are capable of and what we are not capable of. He gives our weaknesses so that we can be humble, and he uses that humility to bring us unto him, so that he can make those weak things become strengths.10 If we believe in Christ, and follow his will, we will be able to accomplish all things.11

One of the greatest impediments to feeling worthy is the feeling we cannot accomplish what the Lord has asked us to do. But He knows our weaknesses, and yet promises that he shall prepare a way for us so that we may accomplish the thing which he has commanded us.12 Relying on the Lord and trusting that we can accomplish what he has in store for us is all part of preparing us to achieve our destiny.13 This is one of the reasons hope is so essential to the plan of happiness.14 I think gays are especially challenged in this area, because so many people teach they are inherently evil. God did not create anyone to fail. He created us to succeed.15 Our divine destiny applies to every one of God’s children. Some may forget that the Family was not a proclamation to the church, but a proclamation to the world.

President Hinckley said “Now we have gays in the church. Good people. We take no action against such people – provided they don’t become involved in transgression, sexual transgression. If they do, we do with them exactly what we’d do with heterosexuals who transgress.”16

Later, as a follow-up to the Larry King interview, he said

“People inquire about our position on those who consider themselves so-called gays and lesbians. My response is that we love them as sons and daughters of God. They may have certain inclinations which are powerful and which may be difficult to control. Most people have inclinations of one kind or another at various times. If they do not act upon these inclinations, then they can go forward as do all other members of the Church.”17

Knowing that we are able to accomplish the Lord’s commandments is an essential step in feeling our worth and fulfilling our destiny. The next logical step is to obey the Lord’s commands. Of course, Satan challenges us here too. The world teaches us that we should embrace all of our feelings. If something feels good, we should do it. Elder Oaks said “All of us have some feelings we did not choose, but the gospel of Jesus Christ teaches us that we still have the power to resist and reform our feelings.”18 These unchosen feelings do not take away our divine nature and destiny. We were made to act, not to be acted upon.19 The natural man acts unrestrained on these desires, and is an enemy of God.20 But we have been given the power to choose for ourselves.21 We fought a war for our agency, for our ability to act, and that war continues here on Earth. Satan would have us believe we are incapable of acting, incapable of obeying God’s commandments, and hence incapable of joy.

As we learn to control our feelings and bridle our passions, we feel better about ourselves.22 We are empowered to do more, and accomplish great things. There is a peace that only Christ can give us.23 This peace is this sweetest thing on Earth.24 As members of the Lord’s church, we dedicate our lives towards bringing this peace to our fellow man.25 This may prove difficult at times, as it may require an abrupt change in the lives of those we teach.26 However, this peace and joy is the purpose of why we are here, and if we are diligent in helping our brother and sisters to change their lives, they too can join with us in the most glorious joy available to man.27

This requires some hard changes. In doing so, we might come off unloving. With regards to the church’s position on same-sex relationships, many feel the church is unloving. But this is really one of the greatest things we can do for those involved in same-sex relationships.

President Packer explains

“We understand why some feel we reject them. That is not true. We do not reject you, only immoral behavior. We cannot reject you, for you are the sons and daughters of God. We will not reject you, because we love you. You may even feel that we do not love you. That also is not true. Parents know, and one day you will know, that there are times when parents and we who lead the Church must extend tough love when failing to teach and to warn and to discipline is to destroy. We did not make the rules; they were revealed as commandments. We do not cause nor can we prevent the consequences if you disobey the moral laws. In spite of criticism or opposition, we must teach and we must warn.”28

Our church leaders teach us correct principles because they love us. Wickedness brings pain,29 and our purpose is to have joy. They do all that they can to teach us joy, and I am so grateful for the love they show to us.

Michael Glatze, who was the founder of the magazine Young Gay America and was of the up-and-coming gay right activists, said after repenting and being baptized into the Lord’s Church, “Homosexuality prevents us from finding our true self within. We cannot see the truth when we are blinded by homosexuality.” He said that before he was baptized, whenever he had a sense that he was doing something wrong, “I would just attribute it to, ‘that’s just the way life is.’…30

How many of us feel that our leaders don’t love us because they tell not to do something? Do we feel they are harsh, unfair, or unloving. It is precisely because they are loving that they teach and warn us against the dangers of our day. They know obeying the commandments will bring us joy. Here is one story how the “tough love” President Packer was discussing brought joy to one woman’s life:

Melissa Fryrear came to believe at an early age that her same-sex attractions made her “detestable” before God. Under this false belief system, she turned away from God and by the time she was 16 had started having sexual relationships with women.

After living with her girlfriend for many years, a Christian co-worker befriended her. She talked with her girlfriend, and they decided to go to a local church. When they entered the small, conservative church, they were welcomed with open arms and the congregation invited her and her girlfriend to the various activities. Doris and her husband D.J. in particular took time to reach out to Melissa.

She recounts “They met me where I was, accepted me with grace, loved me unconditionally and prayed for me fervently. It was through the relationship with them that I was led to make the most important decision of my life. One day in February of ’91, I said quietly in my heart, Jesus, I need You. I receive You. Please, please, please come and be the Savior of my soul and the Lord of my life. And He did…

For months I went around and around with the Lord. I didn’t understand. I argued with Him, begged Him, ignored Him, hurt Him and fled from Him… Over the next months, the Holy Spirit continued to work God’s truth in my heart until I ultimately came to the point where I knew that I knew what I was doing was wrong. Even in my confusion, even in my anger, even in my rebellion, God showered me with His kindness, which led to repentance. In October ’92, by His grace, I repented of my years of sexual sin.”31

Melissa left her girlfriend and is touring the country telling all of how God saved her from the chains of homosexuality.

What would have happened to Melissa if Doris and DJ had adopted the philosophy of day, and had told Melissa that she would never change, and that God wanted her to be in a same-sex relationship? Melissa would have been denied the healing power of the atonement. So many gays are looking for healing, and much of the world is telling them it is impossible.

This is the whole point of the church: to bring us to Christ, so that through his atoning mercy, we can turn all of our sorrows and pains over to him.32 Yet this is a difficult process. Both the young man that Elder Holland interviewed and Melissa talked of severe pain associated with the process.

Alma recounts a similar pain: “But I was racked with eternal torment, for my soul was harrowed up to the greatest degree and racked with all my sins.”33 Yet this pain is a cleansing pain. It brings us to our Savior. Alma continues: “Now as my mind caught hold upon this thought, I cried within my heart: “O Jesus, thou Son of God, have mercy on me… And now behold, when I thought this, I could remember my pains no more; yea, I was harrowed up by the memory of my sins no more. And oh what joy, and what marvelous light I did behold; yea my soul was filled with joy as exceeding as was my pain.”34

The pain might be hard, but it is worth the joy. There are many good-intentioned people, who encourage a sinner to continue in their ways, so that they would not have to feel that pain. I remember on my mission, I was working with an investigator who was trying to quit smoking. She threw away all of cigarettes and didn’t bring any money with her to buy any more. However, when her friends saw how much pain she was going through to quit smoking, they insisted that she take one of their cigarettes. If they were true friends, they would have suffered with her. I think that is why the scriptures ask us to “mourn with those who mourn.”35

I think gay men and women have a lot of suffering to do, and it is our responsibility to help them. Elder Oaks exhorted us that “All should understand that persons (and their family members) struggling with the burden of same-sex attraction are in special need of the love and encouragement that is a clear responsibility of Church members, who have signified by covenant their willingness “to bear one another’s burdens” “and so fulfil the law of Christ.”36 Let us live up to that covenant.

The greatest commandment is to love the Lord thy God, and the second is to love thy neighbor as thyself. All other commandments hang on these two great ones.37 Everything we do should be out of love. From reading the words of our prophets, I know that they love gays and lesbians, and they are doing all that they can to teach them of their divine heritage and help them fulfill their divine potential.

However, there are many forces trying to tell gay men and lesbians that they are incapable of fulfilling their divine destiny, or that they would be happier rejecting their destiny than fulfilling it.

Satan tells gay people who want to obey the commandments of God that it is impossible, he tells gay people who are confused about which way they should go that they should pursue same-sex relationships, and he tells those that are in same-sex relationships that they can’t change. Isaiah 5:20 reads “Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!” So many people with same-sex attraction believe they should pursue same-sex relationships in order to be true to themselves. They avoid marriage because they believe it would be dishonest for their spouse. Those already married leave their marriages because they believe that is what they should do. Those who want to obey the commandments of God are being ridiculed and told they are being dishonest, and those trying to help them are being told they are hurting them. Marriages are being broken apart, lives are being destroyed, souls are lost, and the wounded suffer in silence and are denied the healing power of the atonement, all in the name of acceptance and open-mindedness.

I have chosen to focus on the divine nature and destiny of gay men and women partially because of the political atmosphere, but also because I think it is a strong example of how destructive a false view of one’s identity could be. We all face challenges to our identity. Whatever the temptation may be, there are those lined up to tell us we would be happier embracing that desire rather than going through the pains of repentance. We must be strong. If we remember who we are, we will be able to ignore Satan, and continue with faith and fulfill our destiny. And that will bring true joy, which is the whole reason why we exist.

I also have a testimony of how powerful the Lord is in helping us overcome our struggles. Any struggle can be overcome. I know way too many people who victimize themselves, who falsely believe they are incapable of attaining the Celestial Kingdom, who believe the road is too hard to travel because they are too weak, because some desire is too strong, or some burden is too heavy. Others falsely believe that something that happened in the past, like abuse or a transgression, disqualifies them from the kingdom of God. 2 Nephi 26:5 reads “Doth he cry unto any, saying: Depart from me? Behold, I say unto you, Nay; but he saith: Come unto me all ye ends of the earth, buy milk and honey, without money and without price.”

God is that powerful. He can redeem all who come unto him. This is my testimony. In the name of Jesus Christ, Amen.

1 The Family: A Proclamation to the World
2 Romans 8:16
3 2 Nephi 2:25
4 Mosiah 2:41
5 3 Nephi 27:5
6 Genesis 1:28
7 Romans 8:17
8 Moses 1:13
9 Holland, Jeffrey. “Helping Those Who Struggle with Same-Gender Attraction” Ensign, Oct. 2007, 42–45
10 Ether 12:27
11 Philippians 4:13
12 1 Nephi 3:7
13 Mosiah 4:9-10
14 Ether 12:32
15 2 Nephi 2:25
16 Lattin, Don (April 13, 1997), “Musings of the Main Mormon: Gordon B. Hinckley”
17 Hinckley, Gordon. “What are People Asking About Us?” Ensign, Nov 1998, 70)
18 Oaks, Dallin “Same-Gender Attraction” Ensign, Oct 1995, 7
19 2 Nephi 2:14
20 Mosiah 3:19
21 2 Nephi 2:27
22 Alma 38:12
23 John 14:27
24 1 Nephi 11:22
25 D&C 15:6
26 Mosiah 27:25
27 D&C 18:15-16
28 Packer, Boyd K. “Ye Are the Temple of God” Ensign, Nov 2000, 72–74
29 Alma 41:10
30 Glatze, Michael “How a ‘gay rights’ leader became straight” WorldNetDaily
31 Fryrear, Melissa “The Seeds that Grow: Real Stories – Women” Exodus International
32 Alma 7:11
33 Alma 36:12
34 Alma 19-20
35 Mosiah 18:9
36 Oaks, Dallin “Same-Gender Attraction” Ensign, Oct 1995, 7
37 Matt 22:37-40



Filed under Gay Marriage, Homosexuality, Marriage

13 responses to “Testimony of a Married Man with Same-Sex Attraction

  1. Chairm

    To Joshua for having written this, thank you, that’s courageous.

    The Catholic Church follows a very similiar pastoral approach both to human sexuality and to marriage. It is our obligation to support those struggling with SSA (of whatever degree) but the “world” — the pop culture — competes aggressively.

    Joshua, any advice for the rest of us who don’t experience SSA? From your perspective, how can we best show that we are receptive to hearing and helping — without intruding or over-stepping? Indeed, what have you learned as far as the ways that others have helped rather than hindered you and other SSA folks you know?

    • I would say the biggest thing is just to love them. One thing I love about Melissa Fryrear’s story is that she was in a same-sex relationship when she showed up at a church. She was as lesbian as they came. The couple was able to show love even though they knew she was not obeying the commandments of God. It was through that love, that she came to know God, and repent.

      People with SSA are at different points. Some are just coming to terms with it. Some are living a lifestyle of pursuing same-sex relationships. Some are faithfully married to members of the opposite sex. You really don’t know where they are at. Love them no matter where they are. Too often, people with SSA fear that religious people will only love and accept them if they stay in the closet. This doesn’t allow them to be free and explore themselves. I would rather have someone allow me to make a wrong choice than force me to make the right choice. For Mormons, agency is a big thing. It took courage for me to come out, because I was afraid I wouldn’t be accepted, but I realized I couldn’t go on pretending. Fortunately, I was wrong. I was very much accepted when I came out.

      Be careful what you say about gay people. I know that when you talk about gay people, you know that you refer to those pursuing same-sex relationship. Realize that many celibate people with same-sex attractions consider themselves gay. While you might be talking about those in same-sex relationships, you might not realize there might be others who are celibate or faithfully married who consider themselves to be gay, and think that your comments refer to them as well. Be extremely careful with this!

      If someone does come out to you, be willing to listen. Don’t offer advice unless you are asked to. And don’t judge. Many people with same-sex attractions have made mistakes in the past, or even in the present. We want to know we will be accepted even with all of our baggage.

      So true, Christlike love is really the way to go.

      • Your point on labels is always a troubling one. Homosexual seems to clearly indicate one who has sexual relations with one of the opposite sex, as bisexual clearly indicates one who has sexual relationships with both sexes, but what of those who have inclinations to participate in homosexuality but do not. Accordingly, I referred to you in the clearest way I could think of as “a man with same-sex attractions.” I do not think you fit the definition of a homo- or bisexual. But are you gay? Does that term mean one who is homosexual or does it also include those with that inclination who have not participated in any homosexual activity. I appreciate whatever clarifications you can give me, Joshua, so that I might more properly use the appropriate nomenclature.

      • “with same-sex attraction” is probably the least ambiguous term. I don’t like the word “struggling”. Straight people who struggle with pornography typically don’t say they are struggling with opposite-sex attraction. It just seems weird to me.

        The dictionary defines homosexuality as:

        “sexual desire or behavior directed toward a person or persons of one’s own sex.”

        So the dictionary itself is ambiguous. It could refer to behavior, or it could refer to desire.

        Gay and homosexual are adjectives. It depends what they are modifying. Homosexual feelings, homosexual attraction, homosexual preference, homosexual orientation, homosexual identity, homosexual behavior, and homosexual couple all mean different things.

        Most people, when they talk about gay and straight, refer to sexual orientation, but even this can be confusing. The American Psychological Association has two different definitions:

        “Sexual orientation refers to an enduring pattern of emotional, romantic, and/or sexual attractions to men, women, or both sexes. Sexual orientation also refers to a person’s sense of identity based on those attractions, related behaviors, and membership in a community of others who share those attractions.” http://www.apa.org/topics/sexuality/orientation.aspx (Page 2)

        This really makes it confusing for people with homosexual attractions, but do not identify with the homosexual community.

        In 2009, they introduced another term called “sexual orientation identity”, which seems to follow the second definition, which I discussed in my other post. (http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/therapeutic-response.pdf ) In this statement, they are very emphatic they are two very separate things, but officially, the terms can be interchanged.

        According to this document, I am homosexual because my pattern of sexual attraction has always been for males. Apparently, developing a sexual attraction for my wife does not constitute a change in sexual orientation because sexual orientation is an enduring pattern and one exception does not constitute a pattern.

        So if you go with the second official definition I have always been heterosexual, since I have never identified with the gay community. However the newest statement indicates I am homosexual. If you go strictly by attractions, I am bisexual, because I am attracted both to my wife and to other men. Believe me, I have tried in vain to figure out what my sexual orientation is, to no avail.

        Which is why I would avoid the term. I try to be clear. Same-sex attraction refers to everyone who is attracted to the same sex, while someone pursuing same-sex relationships only refers to those acting on their attractions.

        Gay lifestyle is offensive for people who use gay to refer to sexual attractions, because it indicates sexual attractions can be chosen. It is not offensive for people who use gay to refer to behavior, because it is obvious behavior is chosen.

        My biggest issue is that if I’m not straight, what am I?

      • Another thought to consider-
        If homosexual refers to people who have sex with people of the same sex, and bisexual refers to people who have sex with people of both sexes, then does that mean you do not become heterosexual until you have sex with someone of the opposite sex? Could you, for example, say the Mormon Church teaches that you shouldn’t become heterosexual until after you are married? Could a young virgin looking for another virgin say she doesn’t want to marry anyone who is heterosexual?

      • Sounds like something out of “Minority Report.” Perhaps the terms are defined by an intention of sexual relations? We do use the term celibate for a person who is intending to not have sexual relations, not one who who hasn’t yet but plans on it.

      • But people do “struggle” with obesity, anger management, anorexia, or hyper-sexuality for that matter…anything that they consider a recurring trial in their lives. I thought the phrase fit your situation and I apologize if it offended you. That was very much not my intention. I can see how you would consider the real trial to be about actions, not about inclinations.

        Of the “gay” individuals I have intimately spoken to in my life (perhaps 5 or 6), each one has expressed to me that they deeply wish that they were “normal” and were not attracted to their own sex. Most of them have given up on hope that that will ever happen and have embraced the gay lifestyle. In spite of that, though, I think they would have done it differently if they had had the choice. I understand how you feel your cross to bear has made you stronger and you are appreciative for that. I also deeply commend you for taking that very constructive veiwpoint of the situation and what it has allowed you to do. I think that the righteous who have repented of their sins will share a similar viewpoint in their exaltation. Trials, sin and repentance are all part of the process of eternal progression and exaltation.

        I think you hit the crux of the issue when you differentiated between 1) feelings, 2) actions and 3) community alignment. The terms have been set up to make these synonymous, but as you have said again and again, they clearly are not. And it is harmful to consider them one and the same.

        Well, perhaps it is time to coin a new term. What do you want to be referred to as, Joshua?

      • A man with same-sex attractions is probably the most neutral term. Struggling is fine. I’m not offended. I try to avoid using the term, because like gay lifestyle, many people are offended with it. When in doubt, I prefer not to needlessly offend people. I have seen it as a blessing in my life, and prefer to think of it that way.

  2. J. Stone

    thank you for sharing your testimony. I just finished reading it, and I’m still ruminating on it, so I won’t respond in depth right now. I did want to ask, though, if you’ve ever read any of Neil T. Anderson’s books. Several years ago I read three of them–“Victory Over the Darkness: Realizing the Power of Your Identity in Christ”; “The Bondage Breaker”; and a third title, which I can’t remember right now, that dealt specifically with the issue of overcoming sexual sin. I bring it up because those books focus on the importance of self-identification with Christ as the key to breaking free from the bonds of sin, worry, etc. If you’ve never read them, you might be interested in checking them out, especially the first one I mentioned; it was probably responsible for keeping me alive for a time in my early twenties.

  3. I found out over 2 years ago after 21 years of marriage my husband had been keeping a secret, he has attraction to other men. I almost left him the night he told but I decided to stay. I have to say I have been re-thinking this decision. He has been able to keep this from me for so long. He is able to lie to my face and not bat and eye about it. We are a Christian family and in deep, deep trouble. For what ever reason I do love this man but I don’t trust him. He hasn’t acted out these feelings but our marriage has never and will probably never be the same again.
    Hoping for a miracle in NC.

  4. Joshua

    Dear Hoping for a miracle in NC,

    I fully believe in miracles. I know that with God, nothing is impossible. If both of you are willing to put your faith and trust in the Lord, He will save your marriage. I promise you that. I have seen many couples who thought this revelation would break their marriage, but have instead grown closer together and their marriage is stronger than ever. I know the break in trust is a difficult thing. It is extremely important, but trust can be rebuilt.

    Consider a few things. It is a very difficult thing to accept that you have same-sex attraction. Even today, many Christians teach that you are supposed to hide and pretend to be straight. This was even more prevalent 21 years ago, when you got married. He might not have even come to terms with his same-sex attractions himself. How can he possibly be expected to share something with you that he doesn’t even have a grasp of himself. I came out to my wife before I was married, but you wouldn’t believe how many people told me I was making a mistake and that I should hide my attractions from my wife and pretend to be straight. This is living in modern times in the San Francisco bay area. I am very glad I told my wife, but I also understand the intensity of the social pressure to hide it. Try to understand the immense pressure he was under to hide his attractions. It would have been practically impossible to be completely open with you 21 years ago.

    Next thing I want you to consider, is how hard it would be for him to come to you after he had already hid it. Probably he hadn’t come to terms with it when he married you, or at least thought it would go away once he was married. Now that he has been married awhile, he might realize this was something he will probably have for a long time. You talked of how much you were hurt that he hid it from you. Do you think he wanted to hurt you? If he didn’t love you, he would have no problem coming to you and telling you he was gay and that was the end of it. It was only because he loved you that he feared if you found out you would leave him. I know of way too many guys who are just coming to terms with their same-sex attractions, who are scared to death to tell their wives for fear that they would leave them. In some cases, I think it is better to wait until they are more solid in who they are, because many wives need additional support and encouragement, and if the husbands aren’t solid themselves, many wives will leave their husbands.

    Remember also that trust is a two way street. In order for him to share his feelings with you, he needs to trust that you will not use his feelings against him. This is very challenging for wives, who feel hurt by their husbands attractions, but remember that your husband has been hurt too. A negative response from you hurts your husband more than you can imagine.

    A positive response from you will help him regain trust in you and help him open up more freely. As he opens up to you, you will again learn to trust that he is being honest with you. If you do not let him be honest with you, you will never trust that he is being honest with you. I think this is a general problem between men and women, that is independent of SSA issues.

    Does that make sense? I think too often women unknowingly sabotage their relationship by pushing their husbands away. However, by helping him trust you, you will also learn to trust him, and your relationship will grow. I’ve seen it happen a million times. I know it can happen for you.

    Miracles do happen.

    • @Hoping for a Miracle

      I wanted to let Joshua reply first because he has so much experience in this. He is a living testament to me that men and women with homosexual urges indeed forsake them, get married and be good spouses and parents. I would listen very closely to what he has to say.

      I have never had to deal with what you or your husband are going through, but I have been close to a number of gay men living various lifestyles. I was close with Joshua when he “came out” and have learned a great deal from our intimate conversations.

      I cannot reiterate enough what Joshua said about how bad it is that our society is pushing men with same-sex attractions to forsake the traditional married life for gay relationships. I have known a few married men who “came out” and left their wife and children. I believe it is a sin to leave your marriage and family responsibilities for such a reason, and it is a sin to have sexual relations with anyone who is not a spouse. You more than anyone else are qualified to determine if your husband is bad or not, but remember that temptation left alone is not a sin (because you cannot control it).

      I do not want to in any way dismiss your hurt feelings. This is indeed a hard cross for both of you to bear. You never imagined you would marry a man who would be attracted to other men. You never had a choice in this matter, you never did anything wrong to warrant it, and you (I presume) have tried to be the best wife to your husband. I understand that this revelation attacks you at the core of your own sexual identity, and seriously damaged all trust you have in your marriage.

      That being said, I hope you will open up your eyes to the other “imperfect” marriages and families you see about you that did not choose the situations they are in. There are spouses who suffer from anorexia, anger issues, mental illness, chronic disease, long periods of separation, drug and alcohol addiction, obsessive-compulsive disorders, manic-depressive disorders, co-dependency, etc. There are parents with handicapped children, money problems, foreclosed houses, death in the family. My point is that no marriage or family is perfect. If you were to know all the details of your friends and neighbors, you would realize that. Maybe your cross to bear is heavier than their’s. Maybe it’s lighter. In my opinion, the point (and the challenge) of marriage is not to find the perfect spouse and live happily ever after. It is to do the best with what you have been dealt in life and find the joy in it with God. (This song has always helped me remember this.)

      To help you both “make your garden grow,” I would suggest you check out some resources that can help you both. There are support groups that can help particularly your husband, but also you, thrive despite these challenges. I will ask Joshua to post more, but I know these:

      Adiction Recovery Program

      Finally, I imagine you are wondering why a man who is attracted to other men would ever want to get or remain married to a woman. Author Orson Scott Card described a character like that in one of his books. (quoted here) In brief, it shows three things: 1) That he does indeed love you and want to be with you only, 2) that he wants to be faithful to God and his religious convictions, and 3) that he is deeply committed to marriage and family. It also shows that he is able to overcome strong inclinations to do what is right. Aside from what some may think, marriage is not all about sex and attraction. It is about commitment, mutual friendship and raising children. Sex is important to marriage, but you must not make it the center of it.

      Your husband hurt your marriage deeply when he kept his sexual orientation from you, but as Joshua points out, he was lying to himself for a while as well. I know it will be hard, but you must separate his orientation issues from the trust issues, and begin to work on both. I believe, with God’s help, you are both strong enough to overcome both of these challenges and have a happy marriage again. I will pray for you.

  5. Pingback: Active Mormon Attracted to Men, Marries a Woman | This is Marriage

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s